Representative Van Fossen

Jamie Van Fossen


The Week In Review 
Printer friendly page    

March 11, 2005
E-mail: jamie.van.fossen@legis.state.ia.us 

 Session Week 9
Fax: 563-355-9954

SENATE DEMOCRAT’S RELEASE BUDGET TARGETS
AFTER 8 YEARS IN THE MINORITY DEMOCRATS WANT TO RAISE TAXES & INCREASE SPENDING…SURPRISED?


It is not surprising that after 8 years in the minority, the Democrats would want to raise taxes and increase spending. It’s what Democrats do and it’s what the special interest groups who support Democrats demand that they do.
The Senate Democrats claim that the House Republican (GOP) budget fully-funds Medicaid by “gutting” other programs like early childhood and teacher pay. However, in the House GOP budget, there is a $12 million increase in early childhood (in addition to the $220 million the state currently spends on it) and a $14.5 million increase in teacher pay. While the Senate Democrats want a massive $77 million increase in these two areas, a $26.5 million increase is clearly not “gutting” other programs.
The House GOP plan grows government by 4 percent, which is sensible and sustainable in FY 07 and beyond. The Senate Democrat budget grows government by 10 percent and it appears they have no plan for FY 07, let alone after that. When revenue growth is estimated to be 3.3 percent, increasing spending by 3 times that amount is fiscally reckless.
The Senate Democrats echo the Governor’s claim that the state is spending $235 million to treat sick smokers but is only getting $88 million from the tobacco tax. However, information from Tobacco Free Kids (a pro-cigarette tax increase group), the state spends $235 million treating sick smokers but $150 million comes from the federal government in the form of a Medicaid match. Therefore, the state is actually collecting more money from the tobacco tax than we spend on the state share of Medicaid to treat sick smokers. The Governor has yet to respond to questions about his figures on this.
The Auditor claims that the Governor’s budget spends 8.7 percent more than adjusted FY 05 with a revenue growth of 3.3 percent. Yet the Senate Democrats plan spends even more than the Governor, pushing growth over 10 percent. That the Governor did not spend enough for the Senate Democrats shows how much thirst they have for additional spending increases.
They want to increase the cigarette tax by 80 cents and use $300 million in ending balance and cash reserves. Their targets spend $200 million more than the House GOP targets and $50 million more than the Governor’s Fiscal Year ‘06 budget recommendations.

WHERE IS THE GOVERNOR’S INCOME TAX REFORM BILL?

In early December, Governor Vilsack publicly announced a very broad income tax reform plan.  At the time, Vilsack gave very few details, other than his plan would: 

 

  • Eliminate federal deductibility on income taxes
  • Eliminate the tax on pension income
  • Eliminate the tax on Social Security income
  • Collapsing the current nine-bracket personal income tax to a four-bracket system, due to the elimination of federal deductibility
  • Eliminate several sales tax exemptions
  • Lower the state sales tax from 5% to 4.5% or 4%

 

Shortly thereafter, representatives from the Governor’s Office were asked for more details and when a bill on the Governor’s plan for tax reform would be available to the Legislature and the people of Iowa.  Interestingly, the Governor’s Office said that there would be no bill, and legislators would probably have to “negotiate and work out the details.”  This is because the Governor “likes to throw out big ideas”.

 Since then the Governor’s Office has shown little, if any, interest in negotiating the details of the plan. 

 The only clue legislators and the people of Iowa have as to the Governor’s intentions was contained in an “issue brief” released at the end of January in his budget for Fiscal Year 2006.

 The “issue brief” on income tax reform stated:  “Over the past two years, Governor Vilsack and Lt. Governor Pederson have made transforming Iowa’s economy and providing greater economic opportunity to every Iowan a priority.”  Furthermore, the issue brief boldly stated “an impediment to further growth and business expansion is the complex and cumbersome nature of our state income tax.” 

 As the ninth week of the Legislative session comes to a close, a bill from the Governor on the “cumbersome state income tax” has yet to be sent to the Legislature. 


  Ways & Means Update

Bills introduced in committee this week:

No bills introduced in committee this week due to the legislative funnel.

Bills passed out  of committee this week:

No bills passed in committee this week due to the legislative funnel.
 

   Week in Review Archives

2005 Session
03-04-05
02-25-05
02-18-05
02-11-05
02-04-05
01-28-05
01-21-05
01-14-05

2004 Session
09-07-04
04-28-04
04-16-04
04-09-04
04-02-04
03-26-04
03-19-04
03-12-04 Rep
03-05-04
02-27-04
02-20-04
02-13-04
02-06-04
01-30-04
01-23-04
01-16-04

2003 Session
06-04-03 Special Session
05-30-03 Special Session
05-02-03
04-25-03
04-18-03
04-11-03
04-04-03
03-28-03
03-21-03
03-14-03
03-07-03
02-28-03
02-21-03
02-14-03
02-07-03
01-31-03
01-17-03
01-24-03

2002 Session
05-28-02 Special Session II 
05-10-02 Special Edition
04-22-02 Special Session I
04-12-02
04-05-02
03-29-02
03-22-02
03-15-02

03-08-02

03-01-02
02-22-02
02-15-02
02-08-02

02-01-02
01-25-02
01-18-02

2001 Session
05-04-01
04-27-01
04-20-01
04-13-01
04-06-01

03-30-01

03-23-01
03-16-01
03-09-01
03-02-01
02-23-01
02-16-01
02-09-01
02-02-01
01-26-01
01-19-01

01-12-01

2000 Session
04-28-00
04-21-00
04-14-00
04-07-00
03-31-00
03-24-00
03-17-00
03-10-00
03-03-00
02-25-00